We investigate positive subtropical low cloud feedback mechanisms in climate models which have performed the CMIP6/CFMIP-3 AMIP and AMIP uniform +4K experiments while saving CFMIP-3 process diagnostics on model levels. Our analysis focuses on the trade cumulus/stratocumulus transition region between California and Hawaii, where positive low cloud feedbacks are present in the JJA season. We introduce a methodology to} test various positive cloud feedback mechanisms proposed in the literature as primary explanations for the low cloud responses in the models. Causal hypotheses are tested by comparing their predictions with the models’ responses of clouds, cloud controlling factors, boundary layer depth and temperature/humidity tendencies to climate warming. Changes in boundary layer depth, relative humidity in the cloud layer and humidity advection at the top of the boundary layer are shown to distinguish among the hypotheses considered. For the cases examined, our approach rules out 4/5 of the mechanisms considered in half of the models and 3/5 in the remainder. We argue that unambiguously identifying the positive feedback mechanisms operating in models will in some cases require intervention experiments designed to test specific hypotheses.

Low cloud feedback in global warming projections by climate models is characterized by its positive sign, the mechanism of which is not well understood. Here we propose that the positive sign is primarily caused by the increase in upward longwave radiation from the sea surface. We devise numerical experiments that enable separation of the feedback into components coming from physically distinct causes. Results of these experiments with a climate model indicate that increases in upward longwave radiation from the sea surface cause warming and absolute drying in the boundary layer, leading to the positive low cloud feedback. The absolute drying results from decrease in surface evaporation, and also from decrease in inversion strength which enhances vertical mixing of drier free tropospheric air into the boundary layer. This mechanism is different from previously proposed understanding that positive low cloud feedback is caused by increases in surface evaporation or vertical moisture contrast.

We investigate the dependence of radiative feedback on the pattern of sea-surface temperature (SST) change in fourteen Atmospheric General Circulation Models (AGCMs) forced with observed variations in SST and sea-ice over the historical record from 1871 to near-present. We find that over 1871-1980, the Earth warmed with feedbacks largely consistent and strongly correlated with long-term climate sensitivity feedbacks (diagnosed from corresponding atmosphere-ocean GCM abrupt-4xCO2 simulations). Post 1980 however, the Earth warmed with unusual trends in tropical Pacific SSTs (enhanced warming in the west, cooling in the east) that drove climate feedback to be uncorrelated with – and indicating much lower climate sensitivity than – that expected for long-term CO2 increase. We show that these conclusions are not strongly dependent on the AMIP II SST dataset used to force the AGCMs, though the magnitude of feedback post 1980 is generally smaller in eight AGCMs forced with alternative HadISST1 SST boundary conditions. We quantify a ‘pattern effect’ (defined as the difference between historical and long-term CO2 feedback) equal to 0.44 ± 0.47 [5-95%] W m-2 K-1 for the time-period 1871-2010, which increases by 0.05 ± 0.04 W m-2 K-1 if calculated over 1871-2014. Assessed changes in the Earth’s historical energy budget are in agreement with the AGCM feedback estimates. Furthermore satellite observations of changes in top-of-atmosphere radiative fluxes since 1985 suggest that the pattern effect was particularly strong over recent decades, though this may be waning post 2014 due to a warming of the eastern Pacific.