Prof Manuel J Antunes
Faculty of Medicine,
University of Coimbra,
3000-548 COIMBRA
Portugal
Tel +351-962092677
e-mail: mjantunes@fmed.uc.pt
ABSTRACT
Left ventricular free wall rupture (LVFWR) is a most rare but often
lethal mechanical complication of acute myocardial infarction (AMI). The
mortality rate for LVFWR is described from 75% to 90% and it is the
cause for 20% of in-hospital deaths after AMI. Death results
essentially from the limited time available for emergent intervention
after onset of symptoms. Emergency surgery is indicated and normally the
rupture site is easily identified, but it may not be apparent
macroscopically, corresponding to transmyocardial or subepicardial
dissection with an external rupture far from the infarction site, or
already thrombosed and contained. Repair of the ventricular wall is
usually achieved either by suturing the edges of the tear or closing it
with patches of artificial material or biological tissues, usually using
some kind of biological glue. However, several cases of successful
conservative management have been described. In this Editorial, I
comment on the metanalysis conducted by Matteucci et al, published in
this issue of the Journal, including 11 non-randomized studies and
enrolling a total of 363 patients, which brings a great deal of new
knowledge that can help not only in the prevention but also in the
management of this dreadful complication of AMI.
Left ventricular free wall rupture (LVFWR) is a most rare but often
lethal mechanical complication following acute myocardial infarction
(AMI). The incidence of LVFWR was much higher when thrombolytic therapy
was used and has decreased dramatically with the advent of emergency
percutaneous intervention. Currently the occurrence is around
1%1 .
LVFWR is more frequent as a first transmural myocardial infarction in
elderly patients, with no gender difference. Other risk factors include
arterial hypertension, long episode of angina and delayed hospital
assistance, persistent ST segment elevation and sudden or progressive
hypotension or sudden electromechanical dissociation. Rupture usually
occurs early in the evolution of the infarct, however, late rupture can
occur more than 48 hours after the onset of symptoms in up to 30% of
the cases.2
The mortality rate for LVFWR is said to be from 75% to 90% and it is
the cause for 20% of in-hospital deaths after
AMI.3 Death results essentially from the
limited time available for emergent intervention after onset of
symptoms. The survival rate of AMI patients conservatively treated was
reported to be only 10%. Timely diagnosis and an emergent treatment
strategy are essential for saving patients’ lives. Signs of cardiac
tamponade with hemodynamic instability may occur which should lead to
suspicion of the complication. The echocardiogram is essential in the
diagnosis which should trigger emergency surgery. It has a level of
sensitivity and specificity of over 90%. A pericardial effusion of 10
mm or more is correlated with an increased risk of free wall rupture.
Some authors recommend confirmation of the epicardial fluid by needle
aspiration.
Emergency surgery is indicated and normally the rupture site is easily
identified, but it may not be macroscopically apparent, corresponding to
transmyocardial or subepicardial dissection with an external rupture far
from the infarction site, or already thrombosed and
contained.1 Repair of the ventricular wall is
usually achieved either by suturing the edges of the tear or closing it
with large patches of synthetic materials (dacron, Teflon, etc.) or
biological tissues (bovine or autologous pericardium), usually glued to
the epicardium with some kind of biological glue. Lately, collagen
sponge patches have been used with a good degree of success. However,
several cases of successful conservative management have been
described,4 naturally depending of the size
of the rupture and the capacity of the patient to rapidly promote
thrombosis of the rupture channel.
In a manuscript published in this issue of the Journal, Matteucci et
al,5 from 7 different European institutions,
made a comprehensive literature review to identify articles reporting
outcomes of subjects who underwent surgical repair of left ventricular
free-wall rupture. The primary endpoint was operative mortality. A
meta-analysis was performed to assess the associations of predefined
variables of interest and clinical prognosis. From 3,132 retrieved
articles, the authors identified 11 non-randomized studies, enrolling a
total of 363 patients that, fulfilled the inclusion criteria and were
included in the analysis. They found that “surgical treatment of
post-infarction (LVFWR) has a high operative mortality rate of 32%
which was reduced in patients with oozing type rupture as compared to
blowout type (not defined). Mortality was also significantly reduced in
subjects in whom LVFWR was treated with sutureless (patch) techniques,
as compared to those undergoing sutured repair, while it was increased
in patients who required postoperative ECMO support. Blowout rupture,
sutured repair and postoperative ECMO support are factors associated
with increased risk of operative mortality. No difference in hospital
mortality was found between patients treated under cardiopulmonary
bypass as compared to those in which it was not utilised. A similar
finding with regard to the intraoperative use of intra-aortic balloon
pump.
The authors conclude that “surgical treatment of post-infarction is one
of the most lethal complications of acute myocardial infarction. The
optimal therapeutic strategy is controversial and the current
meta-analysis helps to evaluate the outcome of patients surgically
treated for post-AMI LVFWR”.
As one of the reviewers stressed, during the editorial process, “due to
the retrospective nature of the study, there are inherent limitations
regarding the population. Elements such as echocardiographic parameters
(LVEF, associated MR or RV dysfunction, delay between MI and symptoms
onset, delay between onset of symptoms and surgery and biochemical
markers are not known). Yet, limitations of the scope of the findings
(less invasive surgeries and less extensive disease having better
outcomes) are well identified. Regarding the use of ECMO
postoperatively, indications and outcomes are not clearly described
beside survival”. The authors, themselves, recognize the limitations of
their analysis which are also related to some limitations and
inconsistencies of some of the studies included.
However, this paper brings us a great deal of knowledge, that can help
not only in the prevention but also in the management of this dreadful
complication of AMI. The authors are to be congratulated on this, as
they should also be on a similar study in patients with interventricular
septal rupture (VSR) after AMI, another complex post-infarction
complication, very recently published in another
Journal.6 And the current paper is a
complement of a paper on the same subject (LVFWR), also recently
published,7 on 140 patients from the CAUTION
study database who were surgically treated for post-AMI LVFWR in 15
different centres from 2001 to 2018, from which they concluded that
“surgical repair of post-infarction LVFWR carries a high operative
mortality. Female gender, preoperative left ventricular ejection
fraction, cardiac arrest, and extracorporeal life support, are
predictors of early mortality”, which differs little from the
conclusions derived from the meta-analysis now made.
In another recent study, Formica et al analysed the results in 35
patients who underwent surgery for LVFWR in a 17-year period at their
institution.8 They concluded for “a trend
towards long-term benefit in patients surviving high-risk surgery for
LVFWR repair. Considering the high lethality of LVFWR, the urgency and
complexity of the primary surgical intervention early diagnosis and
prompt surgery play a key role in the management of this complication.”
A final comment: As indicated above, delayed admission to hospital was
identified as one of the risks for LVFWR. Fear to come to hospital
during the current COVID19 pandemic has been a cause for many unrelated
deaths worldwide. One such case was just
described.9 I am quite sure that there were
much more during this period.
REFERENCES
- Honda S, Asaumi Y, Yamane T, Nagai T, Miyagi T, Noguchi T, Noguchi T,
Anzai T, Goto Y, Ishihara M, Nishimura K, Ogawa H, Ishibashi-Ueda H,
Yasuda S.. Trends in the clinical and pathological
characteristics of cardiac rupture in patients with acute myocardial
infarction over 35 years. J Am Heart Assoc 2014;3:e000984
- Figueras J, Cortadellas J, Soler-Soler J. Left ventricular free wall
rupture: clinical presentation and management. Heart 2000;83:499-504
- Hao Z, Ma J, Dai J, Shao Q, Shen L, He B, Jiang L. A real-world
analysis of cardiac rupture on incidence, risk factors and in-hospital
outcomes in 4190 ST-elevation myocardial infarction patients from 2004
to 2015. Coron Artery Dis, 2020;31:424-429.
- Yan L, Wang H, Su B, Fan J, Wang M, Zhao X. Survival after left
ventricular free wall rupture following acute myocardial infarction by
conservative treatment. Am J Emerg Med. 2021;39:21-23.
- Matteucci M, Formica F, Kowalewski M, Massimi G, Ronco D, Beghi C,
Lorusso R. Meta-analysis of surgical treatment for post-infarction
left ventricular free-wall rupture. JOCS 2021
- Matteucci M, Ronco D, Corazzari C, Fina D, Jiritano F, Meani
P, Kowalewski M, Beghi C, Lorusso R. Surgical repair of
post-infarction ventricular septal rupture: systematic review and
meta-analysis. Ann Thorac Surg 2020 Nov 3;S0003-4975(20)31844-0. doi:
10.1016/j.athoracsur.2020.08.050. Online ahead of print.
- Matteucci M, Kowalewski M, De Bonis M, Formica F, Jiritano F, Fina D,
et al. Surgical treatment of post-infarction left ventricular
free-wall rupture: a multicenter study. Ann Thorac Surg 2020 Dec
8;S0003-4975(20)32095-6. doi:
10.1016/j.athoracsur.2020.11.019. Online ahead of print.
- Formica F, Mariani S, Singh G, D’Alessandro S, Messina LA, Jones N,
Bamodu OA, Sangalli F, Paolini G. Postinfarction left ventricular free
wall rupture: a 17-year single-centre experience. Eur J Cardiothorac
Surg. 2018;53:150-156.
- Kassimis G, Karagiannidis E, Triantafyllou K, Karapanagiotidis GT.
Fatal post-infarction late left ventricular free wall rupture in the
era of COVID-19. JACC Cardiovasc Interv. 2020;13:e157-e158.