Neuromuscular characteristics of eccentric, concentric and isometric
contractions of the knee extensors
Abstract
We compared voluntary drive and corticospinal responses during eccentric
(ECC), isometric (ISO) and concentric (CON) muscle contractions to shed
light on the mechanisms underpinning the greater force production
despite lower electromyographic activity (EMG) commonly reported in ECC
than ISO and CON. Sixteen participants (20-33 y) performed ISO and
isokinetic (30˚/s) CON and ECC knee extensor contractions between 110˚
and 40˚ knee flexion, while EMG was recorded from vastus lateralis.
Voluntary activation (VA) was measured during ISO, CON and ECC maximal
voluntary contractions (MVCs). Transcranial magnetic stimulation
elicited motor evoked potentials (MEPs) and corticospinal silent periods
(CSP) during MVCs and submaximal contractions (30% maximum), and
short-interval intracortical inhibition (SICI) in submaximal
contractions. MVC torque was greater (P<0.01) during ECC
(302.6±90.0 Nm) than ISO (269.8±81.5 Nm) and CON (235.4±78.6 Nm), but VA
was lower (P<0.01) for ECC (68.4±14.9%) than ISO
(78.3±13.1%) and CON (80.7±15.4%). Additionally, EMG/torque was lower
(P<0.02) for ECC (1.9±1.1 μV.Nm-1) than ISO (2.2±1.2 μV.Nm-1)
and CON (2.7±1.6 μV.Nm-1), CSP was shorter (p<0.04) for ECC
(0.097±0.03 s) than ISO (0.109±0.02 s) and CON (0.109±0.03 s), and MEP
amplitude was lower (P<0.01) for ECC (3.46±1.67 mV) than ISO
(4.21±2.33 mV) and CON (4.01±2.06 mV). Similar results were found for
EMG/torque and CSP during 30% contractions, but MEP amplitude and SICI
showed no differences among contractions (p>0.05). Reduced
VA during ECC may be at least partly explained by lower corticospinal
excitability, while a shorter CSP may reflect extra muscle spindle
excitation of the motoneurons from muscle lengthening, rather than
reduced corticospinal inhibition.